Boy Scouts New Merit Badge … for Clearcutting?
When one hears the phrase "Boy Scout," one picture that comes to mind is a bunch of youngsters out in the woods, around a campfire, enjoying marshmallows as well as nature. One might assume that on top of "trustworthy," "obedient," and "brave," Boy Scouts might also put protection of the Great Outdoors among their values….
When one hears the phrase "Boy Scout," one picture that comes to mind is a bunch of youngsters out in the woods, around a campfire, enjoying marshmallows as well as nature. One might assume that on top of "trustworthy," "obedient," and "brave," Boy Scouts might also put protection of the Great Outdoors among their values.
A recent investigative series has thrown some cold water on that notion, however, exposing activities of some scouting groups that are cringe-inducing. One piece has a part of the scouting organization clearcutting lands to make profits, just like the boys in Big Timber have been doing for years. Another piece has another scouting group killing threatened salmon to fill a lake for recreation, and then using their political muscle to avoid any penalties.
There’s no doubt that many individual scout troops are doing important things for the youngsters involved, and that the volunteer parents who make the organization work are conscientious caring folks who are trying to help boys become responsible adults.
And any organization that needs money to keep its work going and that supprts a large bureaucracy like the Scouts is likely to have its problems. Heaven knows us folks in the Environmental Movement have been known to not always "be the change" we want to see in the world. (Please don’t make fun of my gas guzzling hybrid SUV.)
The Scouts could use the airing of their dirty laundry to say "Whoops! We could do a lot better." Sadly, it seems the national headquarters of the BSA is choosing to hunker in its bunker, issuing a press statement that in part shoots the messenger: "We are extremely disappointed that [Scouts’] efforts have been portrayed in such a negative light."
That doesn’t exactly seem like the "brave" response.
Ted was an attorney in the Rocky Mountain regional office from 2003–2018. He protected wilderness, roadless areas and the planet's climate on behalf of conservation groups in the Four Corners' states.