Defending Commonsense Energy Efficiency Measures From Delays By The Trump Administration

The standards prescribed by the rules will save about 3% of all the energy used in the United States for all purposes in a year—over a 30-year period. These energy savings will save consumers money on their utility bills, yielding more than $11 billion in net savings over 30 years.

Attorneys

Timothy Ballo

Regional Office / Program

Case Overview

Energy efficiency is the most affordable and effective solution to America’s energy problems. Appliance and equipment efficiency standards save energy, increase the reliability of the electricity grid, reduce consumer energy bills, and decrease pollution.

According to projections by the Department of Energy, standards prescribed by five delayed energy efficiency rules will save about 3% of all the energy used in the United States for all purposes in a year—over a 30-year period. These energy savings will save consumers money on their utility bills, yielding more than $11 billion in net savings over 30 years. The standards will also enhance public health by reducing emissions of carbon dioxide by more than 25 million metric tons by 2030—equivalent to the emissions generated by the annual electricity use of more than 3 million U.S. homes. Additionally, they will reduce emissions of other harmful air pollutants, such as sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides, by hundreds of thousands of tons.

The five rules—which cover air compressors, uninterruptible power supplies, walk-in coolers and freezers, portable air conditioners, and commercial packaged boilers—were developed through a robust public process, and were signed by the Department of Energy in December 2016.

On April 3, 2017, Earthjustice—along with Consumer Federation of America, NRDC, and Sierra Club—notified the Trump Administration of its intent to sue the Department of Energy for needlessly delaying the measures and not doing the final step toward implementing five energy efficiency rules: publishing them in the Federal Register.

Days earlier, on March 31, Earthjustice also filed a lawsuit challenging the Department of Energy’s attempt to pull back efficiency standards for ceiling fans that were published in January. The new standard will cut the energy use of new fans by more than 25%, saving consumers up to $12 billion.

New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman, California Attorney General Xavier Becerra, the states of Connecticut, Illinois, Maine, Massachusetts, Oregon, Vermont, and Washington, the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection and the City of New York are also challenging the delays in the ceiling fan lawsuit and the energy efficiency intent to sue.

A food service specialist with the 55th Force Support Squadron marks down the exact temperature of one of three walk-in freezers at a dining facility.
A food service specialist with the 55th Force Support Squadron marks down the exact temperature of one of three walk-in freezers at a dining facility. (Josh Plueger / U.S. Air Force)

Case Updates

Portable air conditioners are among the appliances affected by the strengthened energy efficiency standards.
February 15, 2018 Press Release: Victory

Court Rules Obama-Era Energy Efficiency Standards Should Proceed

Trump administration dealt another blow in the courts

February 15, 2018 document

Efficiency Standards Order denying motion to dismiss

In December 2016, the Department of Energy adopted four energy conservation standards. It posted the standards on its website so the public could review them for errors before publication in the Federal Register. A year has passed since the error-correction process ended. But the Department still has not published the energy standards in the Federal Register, which is preventing the standards from taking effect. This failure is a violation of the Department's duties under the Energy Policy and Conservation Act....

Rick Perry, in Orlando, Florida, 2011.
June 13, 2017 Press Release

Environmental and Consumer Groups and 11 States Sue Trump Administration Over Stalled Energy Efficiency Standards

Bill savings and pollution reductions from five standards at risk