Challenging Genetically Engineered Alfalfa

Monsanto wants to unleash a strain of genetically modified alfalfa that can withstand the toxic herbicide called glyphosate. The USDA approved the chemical giant’s plans, and Earthjustice sued to protect farmers and dairies, natural strains of alfalfa and wildlife from this toxic threat.

Case Overview

On behalf of a diverse coalition of conventional and organic farmers, dairies and agricultural associations, and environmental and consumer groups, Earthjustice sued the Department of Agriculture in 2011 to challenge its decision to deregulate Monsanto’s genetically engineered strain of alfalfa.

To most plants, as well as many fish and amphibians, the herbicide glyphosate is severely toxic—but one strain of alfalfa is different, thanks to Monsanto’s gene tinkering. The chemical giant engineered alfalfa that is genetically resistant to glyphosate, and the U.S. Department of Agriculture approved it, paving the way for increased use of a toxic herbicide and contamination of natural alfalfa.

The government’s decision will likely also result in additional weeds developing resistance to glyphosate, use of more toxic herbicides to kill such weeds, and contamination of organic and conventional alfalfa crops, with associated socioeconomic impacts and loss of farmer and consumer choice.

In 2012, Earthjustice lost the alfalfa case in the district court, a decision that was affirmed by a higher court in 2013. Earthjustice is developing alternative legal strategies to address the environmental and health issues presented by genetically modified products. Now that the industry has developed new varieties of engineered crops designed to resist other toxic herbicides like 2,4-D, Earthjustice is preparing to challenge the government’s anticipated approval in 2014.

Alfalfa fields. The USDA's decision allows growers to produce alfalfa without restriction or oversight of any kind.
Alfalfa fields. The USDA's decision allows growers to produce alfalfa without restriction or oversight of any kind. (Photo courtesy of Ken Figlioli.)

Case Updates

October 4, 2012 Article

Friday Finds: Climate Change Leaves Wine Connoisseurs Dry

Climate change leaves CA wine lovers with fewer options California’s popular wine varieties may soon be hard to find thanks to drier and hotter temperatures caused by climate change, reports the Center for Investigative Reporting. Though by now farmers are used to Mother Nature’s unpredictability, a slightly wetter or drier season is nothing compared to the extreme weather that the world has been experiencing over the past few years, which is wreaking havoc on California’s vineyards (and those who insure…

July 20, 2012 Article

Friday Finds: The Risky Business of Fracking

Insurance agency says fracking too risky to cover.

May 25, 2012 Article

Friday Finds: Fracked Beer’s Killer Buzz

Breweries worry that extreme gas drilling will frack their beer It turns out that hydraulic gas drilling or fracking doesn’t just contaminate the air and water; it could also mess up your favorite brew, reports Mother Jones. Brewmasters like Brooklyn Brewery and upstate New York’s Ommegang Brewery are raising the alarm about toxic fracking chemicals like benzene making their way to America’s beers through weak fracking regulations that don’t protect an area’s water supply. After all, beer brewing takes a…