Challenging Mexican Border Power Plants

The court order marked the first time a government agency had been explicitly required to consider the climate impacts of the proposed plants.

Clients

Regional Office / Program

Case Overview

Earthjustice filed suit to force the U.S. Department of Energy to conduct a thorough environmental assessment before authorizing operation of power plants owned by U.S. corporations and constructed in Mexico to supply power to the U.S. energy market.

As a result of this suit, the court ordered that the DOE conduct an environmental assessment before authorizing electricity transmission. The order was the first time that a government agency had been explicitly required to consider the climate impacts of the proposed plants.

The Energy Department eventually produced an inadequate environmental assessment, but a legal challenge to it failed.

Electricity transmission lines.
Electricity transmission lines. (Tim Peters / CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)

Case Updates

November 6, 2003 Press Release

Department of Energy Seeks Public Comment on Mexican Power Imports

Environmental groups sued demanding US-run plants should meet US environmental standards

May 6, 2003 Press Release: Victory

Environmentalists Win Lawsuit Over Power Lines from Mexico to US

Bush administration ignored US environmental requirements for US-owned electricity plants built to feed US grid

March 19, 2002 Press Release

Environmentalists Sue over Transmission Lines from Mexico to U.S.

Plan to evade U.S. laws would pollute low-income region of Mexico