Hawaiian Swordfish Fishery to Close Over High Sea Turtle Catch

Turtle advocates dismiss "techno-fixes" that don't protect turtles


Robert Ovetz, Ph.D., Sea Turtle Restoration Project, PhD, (415) 488-0370, ext. 106
Paul Achitoff, Earthjustice, (808) 599-2436

In an unprecedented but legally mandated action, the Western Pacific Fisheries Management Council requested the Secretary of Commerce to shut down the swordfish fishery before it exceeds its allowable “take” of critically endangered loggerhead sea turtles.

If 16 leatherback turtles or 17 loggerhead turtles are hooked by longliners in a single year, swordfishing must be closed for the remainder of the year. This year, 15 loggerheads have been killed so far. And this figure only counts the fleet based in Hawaii under US jusristiction. The deaths caused by international longling fleets is unknown. In May 2005, more than 1, 000 ocean scientists asked the UN to implement a international moratorium on longline fishing in the Pacific Ocean to prevent the extinction of the critically endangered leatherback sea turtle.

The fishery reopened in 2004, after a federal Court mandated four-year closure, but with a requirement to use a new hook technology that the government claimed would drastically reduced the injury and mortality of sea turtles. Environmentalists opposed the re-opening due to questions about the scientific integrity of the study that led to their required use and the fact that the technology was never tested in the Pacific.

“Closures are the only proven technology that works to reduce sea turtle deaths from longlining, said Robert Ovetz, Ph.D., Save the Leatherback Campaign Coordinator with the Sea Turtle Restoration Project. “Using suspect schemes such as circle hooks to skirt our environmental laws to protect endangered species have become the norm under the current Bush administration.”

“Ever since they reopened the swordfish longline fishery in April 2004, the Western Pacific Regional Fishery Management Council and NOAA Fisheries have been declaring they have figured out how to longline for swordfish without killing critically endangered leatherback and loggerhead sea turtles. Apparently, they were wrong. Let’s hope this time they have the wisdom to keep the fishery closed, ” said Paul Achitoff managing attorney of Earthjustice in Honolulu who represented sea turtle conservation groups in litigation that initially shut down the longline fleet in 1999 for killing federally-protected sea turtles.

So called “circle” hooks were used to replace commonly used “J” style tuna hooks in the fishery and continue to be used by longline vessels targeting tuna which are exempted from the rule. A study by the Sea Turtle Restoration Project, “Techno-Fixing Sea Turtles: How the Bush Administration’s Manipulation of Science is Driving the Leatherback Sea Turtle Towards Extinction, ” released in September 2004, warned that the results of a 3 year study of circle hooks were rife with faulty science, politicization, and conflicts of interest.

“The failure of circle hooks to protect sea turtles can be traced directly to the politicization of NOAA Marine Fisheries Service’s science that were then used to justify reopening the fishery, ” Ovetz added. “When the outcome of the study did not fit the desired outcome for industry, the regulations were changed accordingly.”

Shutting down the Hawaiian swordfish fishery should also serve to put the brakes on a proposal approved last week by the Pacific Fisheries Management Council to reopen the West Coast to longline fishing and expand the effort of the CA drift-gillnet fishery, which also injures and kills sea turtles. The Council approved an expansion of the drift-gillnet fishery and its final vote to expand the longline fishery will take place at the its April meeting.

“Now that we have conclusive evidence that circle hooks have failed, the only option left is a closures on longline fishing in the Pacific, until proven actions can be found to eliminate the capture of these endangered species” concluded Ovetz. “The U.S.’s plan to convince other countries to use circle hooks needs to shift to identifying critical nesting and migratory areas that need to be closed.”

The United Nations is currently considering a resolution that supports time and area closures to protect sea turtles. Currently, 1, 007 international scientists from 97 countries are urging the UN to implement a moratorium on longline fishing in the Pacific Ocean to prevent the extinction of the critically endangered leatherback sea turtle. The scientists are joined by 281 non-governmental organizations from 62 countries. The list of signers includes famed primatologist Dr. Jane Goodall, Harvard biologist E.O. Wilson, oceanographer Dr. Sylvia Earle, a National Geographic Explorer-in-Residence, and former U.S. astronaut Bernard Harris, Jr. M.D.


Additional Resources

About Earthjustice

Earthjustice is the premier nonprofit environmental law organization. We wield the power of law and the strength of partnership to protect people's health, to preserve magnificent places and wildlife, to advance clean energy, and to combat climate change. We are here because the earth needs a good lawyer.