Conservation Groups Challenge Weak Air Plan for Pennsylvania

Dirty air threatens public health, air quality in national parks and wilderness areas


Charles McPhedran, Earthjustice, (215) 206-0352


Cinda Waldbuesser, National Parks Conservation Association, (215) 931-15254


Joe Minott, Clean Air Council, (215) 567-4004


Zack Fabish, Sierra Club, (202) 675-7917

Today, conservation groups appealed the weak air pollution requirements recently approved for the state by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The groups are challenging EPA’s decision to approve Pennsylvania’s Regional Haze State Implementation Plan because it will not clean up pollution that threatens human health and natural resources in the state.

Inadequate air pollution requirements for big polluters, chiefly coal-fired power plants, risk the public’s health and air quality at the Brigantine National Wildlife Refuge in New Jersey, Shenandoah National Park in Virginia, Dolly Sods Wilderness in West Virginia and other treasured public lands. The same pollution also harms human health, with children, pregnant women, and seniors most vulnerable.

The National Parks Conservation Association (NPCA), Sierra Club, and Clean Air Council filed the appeal with the Third Circuit of the U.S. Court of Appeals. The groups also filed a petition directly with EPA asking them to reconsider the action.

“EPA’s plan requires no pollution controls at any source—zero,” said Charles McPhedran, an attorney with Earthjustice, a non-profit law firm representing the clean air advocates. “It is unacceptable to allow large polluters to continue to dirty the air of our communities and our treasured national places. EPA must not allow air pollution in our national parks and wild lands, and in our communities.”

“Pennsylvania and EPA are required to protect places like Shenandoah National Park for our children and grandchildren,” said Cinda Waldbeusser, Pennsylvania program manager for NPCA. “Cleaning up the air is critical to ensuring our parks are unspoiled for generations to come. Residents, local business owners, and those visiting the region expect and demand no less.”

A recent court decision means that Pennsylvania’s massive coal-fired power plants are not required under other programs to reduce their emissions at all to protect parks. This plan falls far short of 35-year-old Clean Air Act protections, and will allow pollution to continue fouling air quality—affecting the health of local residents and visitors and degrading national park and wilderness resources.

“The pollutants that cause haze in our national parks are the same pollutants that contribute to heart attacks, asthma attacks and emergency room visits for asthma, chronic bronchitis and respiratory illness,” said Joe Minott of the Clean Air Council. Health related costs from hospital admissions, lost work days, and premature death are the hidden price of continued pollution.

“We should do all we can to protect these treasures, and target the major polluters instead of relying on pollutant trading that will do little to clean up the parks,” said Zack Fabish of the Sierra Club.

About Regional Haze

In 1977, Congress set a national goal of clean, haze-free air in our country’s treasured national parks and wilderness areas. But the EPA and the states have repeatedly dragged their feet and delayed complying with the law. The EPA has violated the requirements of the haze program multiple times, with several courts placing the EPA under consent decrees to comply with the law. Indeed, Congress was so frustrated with delays by the EPA and the states that Congress amended the law in 1990 to speed up the protections for air quality. Thirty-five years after Congress set a goal of reducing air pollution in our national parks and wilderness areas, the EPA and Pennsylvania have only now come out with their first regional haze plan. Yet the plan proposed is woefully inadequate. Instead of requiring the best available pollution control technology, as the law requires, the proposed haze plan includes no emission reductions at any source.

Additional Resources

About Earthjustice

Earthjustice is the premier nonprofit environmental law organization. We wield the power of law and the strength of partnership to protect people's health, to preserve magnificent places and wildlife, to advance clean energy, and to combat climate change. We are here because the earth needs a good lawyer.