Skip to main content

Drain Hetch Hetchy?

Book cover of 'Hetch Hetchy: Undoing a Great American Mistake.'

Cover of Hetch Hetchy: Undoing a Great American Mistake.

Photo courtesy of Heydey

The number one story in California these days is the drought, which has revived water wars that never really go away here.

Which makes even more timely Ken Brower’s new book, Hetch Hetchy: Undoing a Great American Mistake. Hetch Hetchy is a valley in Yosemite National Park that was inundated by a reservoir in the 1920s to create a water source for San Francisco. At the time, it was the biggest environmental battle ever fought in the United States, filling the Congressional Record for weeks.

Passions ran strong then; they run strong still. A vigorous and determined group has been pushing to remove O'Shaughnessy Dam, which drowned the valley—a second Yosemite Valley, on a smaller scale. They argue that the water could be stored downstream; San Francisco need not die of thirst.

Ken Brower, son of David Brower, who killed a few dams himself over a storied career, has written a lively account of the failed campaign to save Hetch Hetchy and the modern effort to "Reverse an American Mistake," complete with speculation about how the rebirth of a wild valley might evolve.

The book is replete with photographs, old newspaper ads and clippings, and passion. It is beyond argument that building a dam and reservoir in a national park these days would be laughed out of court.

Powerful politicians and agricultural interests are horrified at the idea of removing the dam, or at least draining the reservoir, but the proponents of that effort make a very solid case.

Highly recommended, and sure to start a few arguments.

Tags:  Public Lands, Water

Terms of Use

The Earthjustice blog is a forum for public discussion of issues related to Earthjustice’s work. Commenters are asked to stay on topic and avoid content that is defamatory, offensive, abusive or intended to promote commercial interests. Because Earthjustice does not support or endorse candidates for any elective office, comments should refrain from endorsing or opposing candidates for office and political parties, either explicitly or by implication. We reserve the right to remove any comment that violates these terms.