On behalf of the Center for International Environmental Law (CIEL), Earthjustice argued to defend a court order requiring the U.S. Trade Representative (USTR) to disclose a document shared with foreign governments during negotiations to establish a Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA).
The FTAA would have extended NAFTA-type rules throughout the Western Hemisphere. The document contains the U.S. interpretation of terms that would determine the extent of government’s ability to prevent threats to human health and the environment.
CIEL sought to make the document public in a case under the U.S. Freedom of Information Act, but USTR refused to release it. Although the terms of international trade agreements like the FTAA affect the ability of the United States to protect public health and the environment, USTR’s refusal prevented the public from having a voice in how much power the United States should surrender in the negotiations.
“As the U.S. heads into the final months of intense negotiations on the Trans-Pacific Partnership and launches new talks on a potential Trans-Atlantic trade deal, the principles underlying this case take on a new relevance and new urgency," said CIEL President Carroll Muffett. “The American people deserve an open and informed debate about U.S. negotiating positions that have consequences for our rights, our communities and our environment.”
Earthjustice has represented CIEL in suing to gain access to the document. The U.S. district court gave USTR three tries to justify classifying the document. In February 2012, after USTR’s third failed attempt, the judge ordered USTR to release the document. USTR has appealed that ruling.
“Transparency and public participation are hallmarks of democracy. If citizens are kept in the dark until negotiations are completed, they will never be able to provide useful advice concerning rules that would directly affect their lives and health,” said Earthjustice attorney and director of international programs Martin Wagner. “This case is about giving people a role in the laws that govern their lives.”