U.S. Supreme Court Denies Effort to Overturn Tongass National Forest Protections



Court leaves rules in place that protect Tongass rainforest wildlands from damaging logging, road construction


Tom Waldo, Earthjustice, (907) 500‚Äź7123


Niel Lawrence,¬†Natural Resources Defense Council, (360) 534‚Äź9900


Buck Lindekugel,¬†Southeast Alaska Conservation Council, (907) 586‚Äź6942


Catalina Tresky,¬†Defenders of Wildlife, (202) 772‚Äź0253


Virginia Cramer, Sierra Club, (804) 519‚Äź8449


The U.S. Supreme Court today declined to hear a last¬Ā-ditch effort¬†by the State of Alaska to exempt America¬Ā’s largest national forest from a national rule¬†protecting undeveloped, road¬Ā-free national forest areas from logging and road¬†construction. The State sought to overturn a Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruling that¬†kept the Roadless Area Conservation Rule in effect in the vast Tongass National Forest in¬†Southeast Alaska. The Ninth Circuit agreed with a federal District Court in Alaska that¬†the Bush administration improperly exempted the Tongass from that landmark¬†conservation measure.

The Tongass, located in Alaska’s panhandle, is the largest national forest in the United¬†States.

A coalition including the Organized Village of Kake (a federally recognized Alaska Native tribe), tourism businesses, and conservationists joined the federal government in urging the Supreme Court to leave the lower court rulings intact.

“Today¬Ā’s court order is great news for Southeast Alaska and for all those who visit this¬†spectacular place,¬Ā” ¬†said Earthjustice attorney Tom Waldo. ¬Ā”The remaining wild and¬†undeveloped parts of the Tongass are important wildlife habitat and vital to local¬†residents for hunting, fishing, recreation, and tourism, the driving forces of the local¬†economy. The Supreme Court¬Ā’s decision means that America¬Ā’s biggest national forest‚ÄĒthe Tongass‚ÄĒwill continue to benefit from a common¬Ā-sense rule that applies¬†nationwide.¬Ā”

Photo courtesy of Michael Penn
A humpback whale breaches in Seymour Canal with a backdrop of Mt. Sumdum in Southeast Alaska. Read special feature

¬Ā”It feels terrific to put this case to bed once and for all,¬Ā” added Niel Lawrence, senior¬†attorney and Alaska Director for the Natural Resources Defense Council. ¬Ā”Punching¬†clearcuts and logging roads into America¬Ā’s last great rainforest wildland produced¬†nothing but controversy, conflict, and uncertainty. The region can now move ahead on a¬†path that benefits from and sustains the fabulous natural values that attract people to¬†the Tongass. And all Americans can celebrate, knowing that we¬Āfll pass on the crown jewel of national forests to future generations as wild and wonderful as it is today.¬Ā”

“Southeast Alaska has moved on,¬Ā” said Buck Lindekugel, Grassroots Attorney for the¬†Southeast Alaska Conservation Council. ¬Ā”Clearcutting old¬Ā-growth forests in the remote¬†wildlands of our region, with expensive new logging roads no one can afford to¬†maintain, is a thing of the past. We are pleased to see the Supreme Court put this issue¬†to rest and call on the State of Alaska to do the same.¬Ā”¬†

¬Ā”The Supreme Court¬Ā’s decision today is a victory for wildlife in the Tongass National¬†Forest, the state of Alaska, the region and the nation,¬Ā” said Peter Nelson, senior policy¬†advisor for federal lands for Defenders of Wildlife. ¬Ā”The Roadless Rule protects the¬†wildlands that form the heart of America¬Ā’s largest national forest within the most¬†expansive temperate rainforest in the world. Future generations will now have the¬†opportunity to experience the majesty of this ecosystem and the salmon, bears, wolves,¬†birds and the myriad wildlife that depend on it.¬Ā”

“The Roadless Rule protects our intact ancient forests that salmon, bears, and wolves¬†depend upon. Alaska¬Ā’s temperate rainforest is a treasure and today¬Ā’s decision will help¬†keep the Tongass protected from more logging and destruction,¬Ā” said Marc Fink, Senior¬†Attorney for the Center for Biological Diversity.¬†¬Ā

“We’re pleased to see the Roadless Rule upheld again. Over the past decade we¬Ā’ve seen¬†that the rule works. It has protected millions of acres of forests across the country,¬†ensuring that both wildlife and American families have space to live and explore. In the¬†face of a rapidly changing climate, protecting forests like the Tongass is even more¬†important,” said Alli Harvey, with the Sierra Club’s Our Wild America campaign in Alaska.¬†“It’s common sense to protect this wild national icon for future generations to enjoy.”


Bears in the Kootznoowoo Wilderness, Tongass National Forest. Read special feature

The so¬Ā-called ¬Ā”Roadless Rule¬Ā” was designed to protect ¬Ā”large, relatively undisturbed¬†landscapes¬Ā” in national forests from logging roads and clear¬Ā-cuts, while allowing other¬†economic development‚ÄĒincluding hydropower projects, transmission lines, tourism,¬†federally¬Ā-financed public roads, and even mining‚ÄĒto continue.¬†

Today¬Ā’s ruling is good news for the many residents of the region and local businesses¬†who use and depend on the Tongass¬Ā’ outstanding natural values, as well as visitors who¬†come to see America¬Ā’s last great rainforest, teeming with fish and wildlife that thrive in¬†its undeveloped roadless areas. Little practical change is expected, however, since even¬†when the Bush¬Ā-era exemption was in effect, cost and controversy kept almost all logging¬†out of roadless areas. And last year, a federal advisory committee including¬†representatives of the timber industry and the State formally and unanimously¬†recommended against further logging of those wildlands.

The 17 million¬Ā-acre Tongass spans 500 miles of coastal Southeast Alaska, encompassing¬†alpine meadows, deep fjords, calving glaciers, dense old¬Ā-growth rainforest, and over¬†1,000 islands and islets.

Photo courtesy of Michael Penn
A logger climbs down a mountainside while working on Admiralty Island in the Tongass. Read special feature

After much debate and hundreds of thousands of comments, in¬†2001, the Agriculture Department decided that the Roadless Rule should apply to the¬†Tongass but included special measures to blunt the impact of the rule on Alaska¬Ā’s timber¬†industry. Not applying the rule, the department found, ¬Ā”would risk the loss of important¬†roadless values¬Ā” in the¬†Tongass.

When the Bush administration reversed course and tried to exempt the Tongass from the Roadless Rule, it relied on factual findings at odds with those that justified its original decision and ignored the economic mitigation package for the Tongass. It asserted, without support, that the rule was not needed to protect Tongass wildlands and would cause widespread economic hardship. 

The Ninth Circuit¬Ā’s ruling‚ÄĒand today¬Ā’s decision by the Supreme Court not to review¬†that ruling‚ÄĒreinforced the settled rule that federal agencies cannot arbitrarily change¬†policies and ignore previous factual findings simply because a new president has taken¬†office.

Attorneys from Earthjustice and the Natural Resources Defense Council represent the following groups in the case: Organized Village of Kake, The Boat Company, Alaska Wilderness Recreation and Tourism Association, Southeast Alaska Conservation Council, Natural Resources Defense Council, Tongass Conservation Society, Greenpeace, Wrangell Resource Council, Center for Biological Diversity, Defenders of Wildlife, Cascadia Wildlands, and Sierra Club.

The Tongass National Forest, Alaska
The Tongass National Forest, Alaska (Earleliason / iStock)

Additional Resources

About Earthjustice

Earthjustice is the premier nonprofit environmental law organization. We wield the power of law and the strength of partnership to protect people's health, to preserve magnificent places and wildlife, to advance clean energy, and to combat climate change. We are here because the earth needs a good lawyer.