Share this Post:

unEARTHED. The Earthjustice Blog

Going Overboard: Q&A with ship pollution activist Gershon Cohen


    SIGN-UP for our latest news and action alerts:
   Please leave this field empty

Facebook Fans

Related Blog Entries

by Maria Beloborodova:
The Top 10 unEarthed Stories of 2012

Blog posts about Earth's magnificent places and creatures were the most popular themes for unEarthed readers in 2012. By far the most-read post concer...

by Patti Goldman:
Nature Is Up For A Vote Today In Congress

Forty years of environmental progress is under attack today by a vote in the House of Representative on a stop-gap funding measure to keep the federal...

by Terry Winckler:
Massive Attacks on Environment Launched in Congress

Teabag by teabag, the anti-environment faction in the House of Representatives has filled its federal government spending bil...

Earthjustice on Twitter

View Jessica Knoblauch's blog posts
06 July 2011, 2:11 AM
"We’re talking huge quantities of waste going into very pristine habitats."
Gershon Cohen is Project Director at the Campaign to Safeguard America’s Waters, a client on Earthjustice's case regarding wastewater discharge by cruise ships in Alaska.

Recently, Earthjustice staffer Jessica Knoblauch spoke with Gershon Cohen, project director of the Campaign to Safeguard America’s Waters. In June, Earthjustice successfully defended an Alaskan ballot initiative that Cohen co-authored, which called for cruise ships to stop discharging waste into Alaska’s pristine waters.

JK: How did you first learn about cruise ship pollution? 

GC: Back in 1999, I read about how Royal Caribbean had just been convicted for dumping waste into the water. One of the places they dumped it was right near my home in Alaska. I immediately called the Environmental Protection Agency to find out if I could get a copy of their permits to see what they were supposed to be able to discharge. A few hours later, I got a call back from a very sheepish EPA person who said “Gee. They don’t have permits.” I said, “What do you mean they don’t have permits? How could you be discharging millions of gallons of wastewater and not have a permit?” He said, “Well, it looks like they’re exempt. I was like, “No kidding. I wonder how they worked that?” That’s where it all started for me. 

 
JK: How much waste do these ships generate?
 
GC: A typical ship of a couple of thousand passengers will generate about thirty to forty thousand gallons of sewage per day. They advertise these cruises as being a nonstop buffet, right? Well, guess what happens to all that food? At some point, the ship’s got to get rid of it after it’s passed through the people on the boat. They generate tremendous amounts of sewage and urine from all of the feeding that goes on at the trough.
 
They also generate several hundred thousand gallons a day of graywater, which is the water from showers, sinks and laundry facilities, as well as waste from medical facilities, spas and pools contaminated with various chemicals. When Royal Caribbean’s conviction came down, we found out that they were discharging silver nitrate overboard, which is very toxic to fish. They were also dumping perchloroethylene, a carcinogenic dry cleaning fluid.
 
JK: So they dump this untreated waste into the water?
 
GC: At that time, sewage discharges were being treated with a marine sanitation device. But it turns out that these devices had actually never been checked out by the Coast Guard to see if they worked. Not only were these devices not treating the waste, they were actually functioning as incubators for bacteria. The samples of the waste were so hot with bacteria that they were pegging the test at the maximum reading.
 
The other problem was that there was no one watching what these ships were doing. When ships would leave the port, if they didn’t think the Coast Guard would be around, they would get out to sea and install what they called “magic pipes” on the ship that would allow them to just bypass all of the pollution control equipment. The more we looked into it, we found that this was a fleet-wide practice to not treat waste on the vessels. So it was a real problem. We’re talking huge quantities of waste going into some of the most pristine habitats in the world.  
 
JK: In 2006, Alaskans passed a ballot initiative that you co-authored, which called for stricter regulations for cruise ships in Alaska. How did you get this bill to pass?
 
GC: Alaska has a rap of being very pro-industry and not being green. And it’s true to a great degree. However, Alaska also really prides itself on its independence and on a sense of fair play. So one of the things we did in the campaign was to make it clear to people that everyone else in the extraction or natural resource industry had to play by the rules, everyone except the cruise industry. That really resonated with people that this wasn’t fair, and I think that that was a large reason that we won the election. And now, Alaska has the strictest cruise ship rules in the world.
 
EJ: What happened after the ballot passed?
 
GC: In 2009, the Alaskan legislature extended the time period that the cruise industry would have to meet the pollution standards until January 1, 2016. It’s amazing. They gave them nine years.  However, we managed to get the legislature to include the idea that ships would have to meet the best available technology that was out there during the interim. In other words, if there was a ship out there doing a better job than another ship, the inferior ship didn’t have to necessarily use the same waste treatment system, but they had to meet the same level of performance.
 
Unfortunately, the Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) decided to define “best available technology” as the best system that any ship had on it at that time. So whatever you were doing, that would be your best available technology. And of course that’s ludicrous. It makes a mockery out of the whole concept. So we decided to sue and Earthjustice took on our case. We filed our briefs last January and were victorious in the case about a week and a half ago.
 
EJ: The case was argued in Alaska Superior Court. What was the judge’s ruling?
 
GC: He told the DEC that they needed to prove to the public that what they’re considering to be the best available technology for these ships is in fact the best available technology. So now the DEC has to go back and justify the permit limits that they set. Frankly, I don’t think they can do it. We used the DEC’s own data to demonstrate that these better systems exist. So, their whole argument has no legs.
 
EJ: Now that the law has passed, what kind of impact will this law have on ships outside of Alaska?  
 
GC: Well, we were hoping that other states would jump on board. Unfortunately, lobbyists are so powerful in other states that it hasn’t happened yet. Some states like Maine and Hawaii have weaker laws, but in those places the ships self-monitor. I mean, here are these convicted felons self-monitoring their discharges. Can you imagine if you were a bank robber and you went to the local Wells Fargo branch and said, “Hi, I’d like to apply for a job as a teller?” That’s essentially what’s going on here.
 
EJ: Could you tell us which companies are responsibly disposing their waste so that people can support those ships?
 
GC: No. And the reason is because it’s not consistent for any particular line. Some of the ships from some of the lines are better than others. The only reason they’re doing it in Alaska is because they have to do it in Alaska. And the ships that aren’t coming to Alaska, right down the line they have inferior systems.

Listen to Cohen’s entire interview.

Wow What A Great Site! I love the content.
__________________________________
Dayton Roofers
Dayton Roofing

The particular throughout ground trampoline typically is located merely above a pit that is certainly 29 in order to 30 inches strong. To achieve this, you must excavate any hole associated with 12.Half a dozen ft in diameter in the top in the [url=http://happytrampoline.com/]trampolines[/url] which sits over the floor as well as 14.6 foot in diameter for any lowest portion of the opening. In the event the inside soil trampoline must be constructed inside abyss areal, then the opening height need to be 14.6 foot on the top and also 12.Some ft on the bottom. Before starting the particular excavation, it's best to consult a landscaping design professional for their suggestions about neighborhood dirt ailments plus the proper actions necessary for drainage in the local place. The entire within terrain trampoline technique will likely be 33 inches wide large to permit to the trampoline to generally be 3 to 4 inches wide across the quality. In the event the area calls for further measures for great drainage it can be beneficial to increase 3 to 5 ins involving stones to your bottom part of the abyss once for all waterflow and drainage and also prevention of position normal water. Should the area is specially damp, a new sump pump motor are usually necesary likewise. This is usually a issue for that nearby landscape designs skilled with regards to neighborhood garden soil ailments and also water drainage. Your website surrounding the actual in soil trampoline will need to have at the least 18 foot cost to do business clearance and nothing surrounding the vicinity for 6 ft all around. The bottom really should be soft together with impact advertising your lawn, yellow sand, timber particles and other forgiving materials.

Before beginning rooting for that foundation for the inside soil [url=http://happytrampoline.com/]trampoline[/url], accumulate as well as coordinate many of the integrated computer hardware along with elements for the within ground [url=http://happytrampoline.com/]trampolines[/url]. These elements typically add the subsequent: leading shape sectors, bottom part body portions, aspect solar panels, rubberized advantage guardian strip, mat collection, jumping surface area, spgs, products, nuts, washers, anchoring screws as well as a resource. After you've done which, set your solar panels out in a huge group of friends. Web site shipped to the bottom shape will certainly assist in paying attention to the actual opening with regard to excavation. Be sure the planting season openings at the top body are usually dealing with upwards. Affix products as well as anchoring screws however just generally permitting for motion of the system through set up as well as bolt positioning. Having a prolonged screw driver allow gap alignment is mandatory. Assemble the low ring once again making anchoring screws freely attached. Overlap Three or more sections on the floor on 1 another to line-up divots. Affix top openings to screen holes and to top shape together with secure along with units on the solar panel facet, enthusiast and also washer dryer about framework aspect, keeping early spring pockets experiencing upwards ahead frame, once more loosely stiffened. Attach upper and lower frame jewelry making use of proper bolts as well as cleaners as well as insane along with units, leaving almost all freely fixed. Connect one particular screen at any given time coming from lower screws for you to top using an Allen wrench. Keep on until finally full and then make tighter just about all bolts. Location frame in abyss along with back fill earth in making shape increasing about edge of piece of equipment. Deploy the inside springs. You'll encounter shape and yoga exercise mat openings for every single spring. Check carefully your routine to discover that spring is actually attached. Put in the extra edge guardian pad making sure almost all cable connections are full. Perform protection inspections and relish the in floor trampoline.

[url=http://girlgamesplaza.com]girl games[/url] are generally understandably distinctive from the types of games boys enjoy playing on the internet. When you head online with the child, you can find the girl enjoying loads of games create actually recognized was around. Main amongst these are move winning contests along with dress up games. Other [url=http://webcoloringpages.com]coloring pages[/url] incorporate more compact variations of the along with fast-paced thinking games for instance cooking food game titles.

Get into character Video games
Easily one of the most popular [url=http://topcookinggames.com]Cooking games[/url] online, dress up video games enable your little one try out manner as well as layout. The gown way up video games combine doll angles, much like Barbies, and related trends Your kids can easily outfit superstars, superheroes, mermaids, goblins, Goths and then any volume of additional interesting aspects. The dress upwards games tend to be shared with other folks in the neighborhood that will supply regarding virtual representations of personnel about sociable web sites or even for prize draws frequently managed upon clothes way up game titles sites.

Function Doing offers
Popular with little ones alike, position playing video games enable incredible imagination by way of make-believe. While some position playing video games give attention to enthusiast as well as fights, other people which are most liked with ladies concentrate more on relationships along with existence in just a local community. How many part playing video games can be growing on the internet, however your child will probably build a preferred quickly. While in the part playing games, your child can take over a figure. By logging into sites to that identical figure, the girl generates points simply by winning contests on and on by means of various quests. The actual factors as well as funds are generally then employed to progress the character as well as the role play issues with the adventure.

Food preparation Online games
Yet another entertaining variation associated with [url=http://webcoloringpages.com]coloring pages[/url] are generally cooking games. In preparing food video games, the child spends internet time in a very digital kitchen or perhaps going to a virtual bbq grill. The game sets a period restrict about how speedily the girl should switch burgers as well as puppies around the bbq grill or how rapid she can obtain garlic bread in and out of the actual oven. The cooking food online games need experience and arranging. You will need to assume what is springing up following although still working around the existing purchase. At the same time meals are using up about the barbecue grill in which are unable to ensure it is on to an order as well as items copy if you are not keeping the suitable stability. Food preparation game titles tend to be fast-paced along with exciting. Because you development collected from one of level to another, the particular strength gets hotter rendering it far more interesting.

Compose Video games
Within a smaller sized edition associated with liven up online games, compose game titles allow women to apply their own comprise skills. From the video games, the toy doll foundation stares in bare pores and skin. It is your job that will put the correct amount involving make up onto the encounter on the lifelike dolls. You then have a wide selection of vision dark areas, lip ships and glosses, mascaras and also attention colours. Lots of the make up games including hair-styles in addition so that your ultimate design is substantial and also exciting in a completely facelift. You can get back many occasions and produce all new tries the identical girl doll using a little bit of creativeness.

Also, for purchasing low-cost [url=http://www.mafiawars-maniac.com]Mafia Wars[/url] loot iteams, within a sensible and also payment shipping and delivery approach, check out our own low cost [url=http://www.mafiawars-maniac.com]Mafia Wars[/url] on the internet loot iteams go shopping. you are going to ger free delivery together with much more faciailites. As well as, if you would like enhance your web site for the most powerful Search engines like google Optimisation benefits, then you can certainly have a look at our own low-cost [url=http://www.iseohelp.com]SEO Help[/url] internet site Cheap [url=http://www.iseohelp.com]Cheap SEO Packages[/url] at the same time.
http://www.skydivecenterspa.com/tphp//pceguestbook.php3?Lang=G&Option=Add http://www.steamphone.de/fussball-wm-2010-sudafrika/fussball-wm-2010-sue... http://riderzsyndicate.com/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=9608 http://hotroad-webtv.com/yybbs/yybbs2.cgi http://www.chathouse-kyoto.biz/contents/form/index.php

[url=http://www.hdmitovgaadapter.net] mini hdmi to vga adapter [/url]

The new program that we have replaces custom rubber stamps and virtually any stamp that is used for paper and pdf marking. It completely automates the marking process selectivly marking any or all pages and, if desired, printing an entire document but only stamping seletect pages! Try that manually. Looking forward to comments.... hopefully.

kuchnie krakow

A scroll table tabletable row runs horizontally in a line across a table tabletable and is normally made up of several boxes with information rows table. When you draw a table tabletable on a piece of paper, you are creating columns and rows rowsrows. Each horizontal line of boxes is a different table tabletable row. Often, the row at the top of the web grid is used to create headers, which tell the reader what information can be found in the boxes below it, also known as the column. For example, the first three boxes in the first row of a table tabletable in a teacher’s attendance book might read "Student's Name," "Present," and "Absent."

Table rows are commonly used in HTML to create tables and to format a web page. The HTML tag for a grid data is . Within each row, the tag must be added for each new box the user wants to create in that row. A new table row must be created to move down to the next line sorting table and start a set of boxes below the first. This example shows a table with three table rows and three table columns.

biuro rachunkowe - projekty tanich domow jednorodzinnych

I really like this website! I love the content.
__________________________________
Dayton Ohio Roofers

carb blocker How is it that just anyone can create a blog and get as popular as this? Its not like youve said something extremely impressive –more like youve painted a fairly picture above an issue that you know nothing about! I dont want to sound mean, right here. But do you truly think that you can get away with adding some quite pictures and not seriously say something?

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <p> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.