Skip to main content

Court Rules Montana Illegally Approved Gold Exploration License Near Yellowstone

Victory: Montana Department of Environmental Quality must complete more extensive environmental review of Lucky Minerals’ drilling plan
Emigrant Gulch aerial view looking east from Emigrant Peak. There are mine claims on both sides of the gulch on both private and public land.

Emigrant Gulch aerial view looking east from Emigrant Peak. There are mine claims on both sides of the gulch on both private and public land.

Photo courtesy of William Campbell
May 29, 2018
Livingston, MT —

A Montana district court ruled last week that the Montana Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) illegally approved a gold exploration drilling license for Canadian mining company Lucky Minerals Inc. in the Emigrant Gulch area just north of Yellowstone National Park. The Court found that the DEQ gave “unwarranted deference to Lucky’s proposal, without conducting an independent analysis of alternatives.” The Department must now conduct a more extensive review of the proposed drilling plan. 

The lawsuit was brought by Earthjustice on behalf of conservation groups Park County Environmental Council and Greater Yellowstone Coalition. The groups argued that DEQ failed to consider the significant harm to Park County’s environment and economy from full-scale mine development, and did not account for the risks posed by the project to the Yellowstone region’s iconic grizzly bear and wolverine populations, as well as to water quality in Yellowstone River tributaries. 

The DEQ now must conduct a more thorough analysis via an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for the drilling permit to be validated.

“The court’s ruling recognized that exploratory drilling is the leading edge of a much larger threat to these sensitive lands in Yellowstone’s gateway,” said Earthjustice attorney Jenny Harbine, who represented the groups. “We will continue our fight to stop Lucky’s plans to profit by placing our water, wildlife, and magnificent natural landscapes at risk.” 

Local residents and businesses have long expressed concerns that the mineral exploration near Montana’s Paradise Valley is just the first step in Lucky’s plans to develop large-scale gold mining that will threaten Park County’s tourism economy, which depends on clean water and access to the County’s spectacular public lands. “We went to court to fight for our community and the resources that help make it so special, but this victory doesn’t end that fight,” said Park County Environment Council Executive Director Michelle Uberuaga. “We won’t rest until Lucky Minerals leaves town for good.  

“This is great news and simply more proof that Yellowstone is more valuable than gold,” said Greater Yellowstone Coalition Executive Director Caroline Byrd. “The court agrees with us that DEQ didn’t take a ‘hard look’ at the whole picture of Lucky’s proposal and the rights to minerals under public lands that Sec. Zinke, Sen. Tester, Rep. Gianforte, the Forest Service and more than 400 business owners have all agreed should be off limits to protect our economy and way of life.”

Read the decision.

Your timing is perfect …

At Earthjustice, we’re more than just lawyers in a courtroom. We’re a nonprofit in the business of building a better future for our planet. Our 135 lawyers measure success in clean air, clean water, and safeguards for communities across the country. We stand alongside our hundreds of public-interest clients at the frontlines of the fight for a better today and tomorrow. Case by case, our lawyers face off against deep-pocketed interests and today’s unprecedented attacks on our environment, health, and climate — and we win.

You have only a few days left to make a tax-deductible donation investing in our work that will immediately triple in value, thanks to a generous first-ever match offer from our Board of Trustees.

Whether you give $5 or $5,000, this will be the best investment you make today.

(Not convinced? Research our legal victories and see our clients, all of whom we represent free of charge.)

Contacts

Jenny Harbine, Earthjustice, (406) 586-9699 

Beth Kampschror, Greater Yellowstone Coalition, (406) 556-2819

Michelle Uberuaga, Park County Environmental Council, (406) 223-4714

Overruling Trump.