Conservation Groups Challenge Decision to Allow Grazing in Endangered Species Habitat
On behalf of the Center for Biological Diversity and the Forest Guardians, Earthjustice is challenging a district court ruling that grazing, which admittedly violates the Endangered Species Act, may continue unabated in certain parts of national forests in Arizona and New Mexico.
Ken Goldman, x. 233
Earthjustice today took action to protect a threatened species of minnow from irresponsible grazing practices in the Southwest. The law firm filed its brief in a case against the Forest Service that was filed last June. On behalf of the Center for Biological Diversity and the Forest Guardians, Earthjustice is challenging a district court ruling that grazing may continue unabated in certain parts of national forests in Arizona and New Mexico. The groups specifically charge that inadequate research was conducted.
“The Forest Service has admitted that grazing is likely to harm these minnows and that its analysis of the impacts is not adequate,” said Earthjustice attorney Susan Daggett. “We are asking for grazing on these lands to be curtailed until the proper procedures are followed.”
The case addresses the Forest Service’s refusal to stop grazing while it considers the impact livestock grazing could have on endangered species on – 11 grazing allotments. Attorneys are also challenging the ruling that under the Endangered Species Act, the Mangas Valley allotment in the Gila National Forest is safe for grazing.
Livestock grazing can degrade crucial riparian areas until they are no longer suitable habitat for the species they support. By depleting vegetation, overgrazing can impact both soil and flood patterns, permanently altering the nature of the ecosystem. For the loach minnow, this habitat destruction has led to a range reduction of at least 80 percent from their historical range.
“We know that irresponsible grazing practices can bring irreparable harm to these critical watershed habitats,” said Daggett. “We also know that these minnows likely are in grave danger of losing their habitat. The Forest Service hasn’t even finished assessing these risks. Yet grazing continues. That’s a big problem.”
The plaintiffs’ opening brief (01-16092) was filed in the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
Earthjustice is the premier nonprofit environmental law organization. We wield the power of law and the strength of partnership to protect people's health, to preserve magnificent places and wildlife, to advance clean energy, and to combat climate change. We are here because the earth needs a good lawyer.